The British History Challenge- Numbers #1-3-

So whilst i’m stuck here for the time being i thought i might do something productive whilst i wait for the hypothetical train out of here (seriously… it’s been severely delayed). Namely, the challenge is to watch almost the entirety of british history on film… or as much as possible. Hopefully, by the end i will be able to say something about it… not least that an awful lot of people in british history look like Michael Caine.

The first thing to do was make the list and construct it based on what films are available, what goes where according to everything else, conflicting ideas etc…. In the end the result was a list of sixty films starting with ‘Centurion’ in AD 117 and finishing with ‘The Queen’ in 1997.

So lets start at the very beggining

#1: Centurion

  •  General Opinion:  Overall watchable. Starts off well but lags a little in the middle.
  • Review: A fairly run of the mill action film with lots of blood and gore that tells the tale of the destruction of the ninth legion in 117 AD. The acting is good.  Not poor but not briliant either as none of the characters really jumped out as individuals. In terms of overall plot it just about holds itself together. The use of the epic scenery to set the scene is done particularly well.
  • The credits however look cheap and amateurish and marr the whole aspect of the film slightly.
  • Rating: 5/10- Not bad, but not good enough to keep my attention for it’s two hour run time.

#2 The Last Legion

  • General Opinion: What… The… F**k?
  • Review: Honestly… The whole idea of this film is great. The idea of the last roman emperor going to britain to find the previously decimated ninth legion to save the roman empire is a good one and has potential. This film should be done on an epic scale with high pitched, raging battles and stunning landscapes… What we get instead is Colin Firth… who really doesn’t suit the role of a Roman general, Lucious Vorenus from the ‘ROME’ tv series pulling silly faces for the entirety of the film, Ben Kingsley doing god knows what accent… and an Indian Ninja Woman… YEP… AN INDIAN NINJA WOMAN!
  • The film is far too short and plot heavy to be done well. More time should have been spent setting up on the whole Vortigern scenario rather simply cramming it into the last half an hour. The battles are far too short and any part of the film that could have been done an epic scale just isn’t. And the less said about historical accuracy the better.

Rating: 3/10- As Ben Kingsley says at the end “We still need heroes… Don’t we?” Well… this film definately needs a hero to save it.

#3 Tristan and Isolde

  • General Opinion: Looks good compared to The Last Legion
  • Review: It has some of the epicness that the previous film lacked and the battles are much better (If still a little on the short side). The basic plot pre dates that of the Arthurian romances and generally holds up for most of the film- probably because those medieval types knew how to tell a good story.  Too bad the same can’t be said for the acting. The title characters (James Franco and Sophia Myles- AKA Harry Osborne and Madame Du Pompadour!) have no chemistry whatsoever and most of the supporting characters do nothing but whinge throughout. The accents are all over the place as well. Like it’s predecessor on the list, this film deserves better. The problem is that it just never seems to get off the ground and as such, by the end i didn’t really care what was happening.
  • Rating: 4/10- Not an appaling film… but not a good one either. I’ve seen worse.

So far then on this journey through British History we have seen a legion decimated, an empire fall and a country in the grip of a dark age… Now we face a huge gap of about four hundred years. The next film ‘The Vikings’ takes us into the medieval era. Let us only hope the standard of film gets better!

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “The British History Challenge- Numbers #1-3-

  1. You could have used Beowulf… either the shocking Ray Winston version… or the ‘not so great on the cgi’ version with gerard butler!
    That would then take in the Saxons
    There is also King Arthur…. (yes yes shockingly awful!) but again takes in the coming of the saxons!
    I’m sure once upon a time I also heard about a film to do with Ecgfrith?! Hmmmm I shall search and comment again!
    🙂

    • Beowulf isn’t included because it’s set in Denmark. I did consider it but decided against using it for that reason. I didn’t know about Seige of the Saxons but i will definately try to find it and include it as a bonus one at the end.

      As for King Arthur… well i knew that was awful and it sort of clashed with the Last Legion in terms of time frame which is why that one isn’t on the list.

      James.

  2. Nope I can’t find it…
    but along the same route of the shocking King Arthur film… there was also seige of the saxons (1963)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s